Cleveland Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) Matt Storey has joined counterparts across the country in calling on the Government to reject proposals for police “mega forces”.
Cleveland Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) Matt Storey has joined counterparts across the country in calling on the Government to reject proposals for police “mega forces”.
Matt has signed a joint letter to Prime Minister Andy Burnham, asking him to stop proposals to shrink the number of territorial forces in England and Wales from 43 to between eight to 10.
It has been signed by 31 policing governance leaders, including Police and Crime Commissioners, Police, Fire and Crime Commissioners and Deputy Mayors from across England.
Substantial consequences
The letter warns of “substantial consequences” for communities, victims and witnesses if planned mergers go ahead.
It also outlines fears that mergers will cause disruption to local policing and ongoing investigations as well as go against the principles of local accountability and democracy.
Matt said: “I have already made clear my concerns about proposals to replace local police forces with large regional organisations, but it is important that the voice of communities such as Cleveland is continually heard in this debate.
“The people of Cleveland deserve a police service that understands the distinct challenges and opportunities across Hartlepool, Middlesbrough, Redcar and Cleveland, and Stockton-on-Tees. Local policing works best when local priorities are shaped by local people and when communities can clearly see who is accountable for the service they receive.
“There is a wider question of accountability. At a time when Government is rightly talking about devolving power away from Whitehall and bringing decision-making closer to communities, it seems contradictory to consider policing structures that could move decisions further away from the people they affect.
“While I support efforts to improve efficiency and ensure the best possible use of public money, this must not come at the expense of local policing, local partnerships and democratic accountability.”

The real challenges
Matt said the current debate around force size risks distracts attention from the real challenges facing policing.
He said: “This debate is focusing on the wrong issue. What matters is whether communities have the officers, resources and local accountability needed to keep people safe.
“The evidence simply does not support the argument that bigger automatically means better. Cleveland Police is one of the smallest forces in the country, yet it is also one of the most improved.
“For years, Cleveland Police has been disadvantaged by an outdated funding formula despite policing some of the highest levels of demand in the country. As a result, the force continues to face significant financial pressures and remains more than 220 officers below 2010 levels.
“The priority should be fair funding, not bigger forces.”
Limited Support
Public polls nationally have shown limited support for the creation of so-called “mega forces”, with many people favouring locally accountable police services over large regional organisations.
Matt said: “Any proposal of this scale must be backed by clear evidence that it will improve public safety, strengthen accountability and deliver better value for taxpayers.
“Given the challenges facing policing, the Government must also demonstrate why force mergers would deliver greater benefits than investing in frontline policing and fairer funding. At present, that case has not been made.”
Read to the letter to the Prime Minister in full.